Identifying Effective Combinations of Economic Policy Measures for the Coronavirus Recession in Europe

DIW Weekly Report 23 / 2020, S. 263-273

Kerstin Bernoth, Marius Clemens, Geraldine Dany-Knedlik, Stefan Gebauer

get_appDownload (PDF  488 KB)

get_appGesamtausgabe/ Whole Issue (PDF  2.4 MB)

Abstract

As the coronavirus pandemic spread across the globe in early 2020, the European Central Bank as well as national governments in the euro area enacted or announced numerous economic policy measures to counteract the severe economic consequences of the resulting lockdowns. In this paper, the immediate effect of the announcements on government bond and stock markets are estimated in a panel study. The results show that the ECB’s monetary policy measures barely had a stabilizing effect on the financial markets in the short term. With the exception of the announcement of Germany’s Economic Stabilization Fund, the fiscal rescue packages of other national governments and the EU did not lower government bond yields. In contrast, suspending fiscal rules and relaxing banking regulations had a calming effect on the markets, especially the government bond markets. In conjunction with fiscal policy measures, EU-wide measures in particular, they were able to stabilize the stock markets. Overall, the results show that policy action on the part of individual governments is not sufficiently effective on its own. To be effective, measures must be taken by Member States together. A joint crisis mechanism, such as the European Recovery Plan announced by the EU, could be quite efficient.

Geraldine Dany-Knedlik

Research Associate in the Macroeconomics Department

Marius Clemens

Research Associate in the Forecasting and Economic Policy Department

Stefan Gebauer

Research Associate in the Forecasting and Economic Policy Department

Kerstin Bernoth

Deputy Head of Department in the Macroeconomics Department



JEL-Classification: E5;E44;E50;E62;G14
Keywords: Covid-19, announcement effects, monetary policy, fiscal policy, macroprudential policy, euro area
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18723/diw_dwr:2020-23-1